When comparing Sniffy to Captain Kirk we have to realize that Sniffy is a computer program and Captain Kirk is a real rat with hundreds of different actions.
During the shaping process it only took about 15 minutes to train Sniffy while it took eight days to train Captain Kirk. This was kind of discouraging to our team because we felt that we should have gone in and completely shaped our rat in one day.
In our magazine training of Sniffy it was easy because you could see when Sniffy had associated a food pellet with food and when she did not. When we were Magazine training Captain Kirk we were never really sure if we had accomplished our goal or not. Sometimes even when we were shaping we were not sure if we had done it right or not.
With Sniffy we were able to get him over to the corner pretty easy and get him to rear easily but when it came to our rat the behaviors were so sporadic at times that we would constantly have to back up and then move forward a little.
I think working with Sniffy allowed me get my feet wet before training Captain Kirk. Getting my feet wet was good because I was so nervous I was going to mess up. After using Sniffy I was less scared and had a better idea of what was coming at me. Overall even though Sniffy sort of set me up for some disappointment I feel that it was a useful tool in getting me ready to train my own rat because of this I believe Sniffy should be used in the future.
An example of FR 2 cumulative record